Coffee subscription: 50% off your first month
Siip Coffee 101

How to Figure Out What Coffee You Like

By Siip5 min read
A cortado on a marble table beside a Siip taste profile card and the app scanning a bag of coffee

"Surprised by liking these notes!" one Siip rater wrote after trying a light roast from El Salvador. "Still trying to dial in if I like fruity, sweet, bright. And I still don't know but I do know I liked this!"

Most of us are in the same position. We know when we like a coffee, but very few of us can say why. That is not a failing, because the words on a coffee bag were written by professionals, for other professionals. It does make it hard to buy the next bag with any confidence.

There is a simple way through it, and it does not start with learning the vocabulary. Taste three coffees that are clearly different, rate each one, and look at what your favorite has that the others don't.

What people say, and what they rate

When people sign up for Siip, we ask what they like. Then we see what they rate highly. The two often don't match.

  • Roast. Six in ten people say they prefer medium roast. Then they rate lighter roasts higher. Light roasts are loved 43% of the time, compared with 33% for medium.
  • Flavor. Chocolate and nutty are the two flavors people most often say they want. Floral and berry coffees get the higher ratings.
  • Habit. Even what people buy is a weak guide. Among people with ratings in two or more roast levels, 36% rated a different roast highest than the one they rate most often.

Nobody is lying. A stated preference is a guess made before tasting. Most of us answer with what we've had before, and most of us have had medium roast with chocolate notes.

So skip the guessing. Taste, and keep score.

The three-coffee method

You need three coffees that differ in one clear way, and a way to remember what you thought.

1. Pick three that are far apart. Three medium roasts from Colombia won't teach you much. Try:

  • a light roast from Ethiopia or Kenya, which will tend to be fruity and bright,
  • a medium roast from Colombia or Guatemala, which will tend to be balanced,
  • a medium-dark roast from Brazil or Indonesia, which will tend to be heavier, with chocolate and nut notes.

A cafe that sells bags will often brew you a cup of each, which costs less than three bags.

2. Brew them the same way. Same method, same amount of coffee, same water. Otherwise you're comparing your brewing, not the beans.

3. Rate each one before you read the label. Loved it, liked it, it was OK, or not for me. Go with your first reaction.

4. Look at what sets your favorite apart. Was it the lightest? The fruitiest? From a different part of the world? That's your first real clue.

You don't need to have the answer yet. Like the rater at the top of this page, you only need to know that you liked it.

What to pay attention to

You don't need tasting notes. Three plain questions cover most of it.

  • Bright or mellow? Bright coffee has a juicy, citrus-like snap. Mellow coffee is soft and round. This is acidity, and it's the thing people disagree about most.
  • Light or heavy? Some coffees feel like tea. Others feel closer to whole milk. This is body.
  • Fruit or chocolate? Most coffees lean one way: fruity and floral, or chocolate, caramel and nuts.

If you can answer those three for the coffees you love, you can read almost any bag.

Then keep going

Three coffees give you a direction. Ten give you a pattern.

Expect some misses along the way. People love about 4 in 10 of the first coffees they rate, and fewer as they explore. The misses are useful: one "not for me" tells you more than three "liked it"s.

Let your ratings do the choosing

Keeping score is the part most people skip, and it's the part that works.

The Siip app does it for you. Scan the bag, rate the coffee, and it builds a taste profile from your ratings: the flavors, roasts and countries you rate highest. Then it shows a match score on coffees you haven't tried yet, and tells you why.

Those ratings are also what a Siip subscription uses to choose your coffee. When subscribers rated the coffees we sent them in their subscription boxes, they liked or loved 86% of the coffees in their fourth box, up from 62% in their first. Across all coffees rated in the Siip app, that share is 76%.

Your taste is not the average. Most people's favorite country isn't the most popular one, and 7 in 10 have a favorite other than Colombia. We think the best way to find yours is the simplest one: taste, rate, and let the pattern show itself, one cup at a time.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find out what kind of coffee I like?
Taste three coffees that are clearly different, such as a light roast from Ethiopia, a medium roast from Colombia and a medium-dark roast from Brazil, brewed the same way. Rate each one, then look at what your favorite has that the others don't.
Why don't I like the coffee I thought I would?
Stated preferences are guesses. In Siip's data, six in ten people say they prefer medium roast, then rate lighter roasts higher.
What should I notice when I taste coffee?
Three things: whether it's bright or mellow, whether it feels light or heavy, and whether it leans toward fruit or toward chocolate and nuts.
How many coffees do I need to try?
Three will give you a direction. About ten rated coffees is enough to see a clear pattern.
Does a coffee subscription matched to your taste work?
In Siip's data, subscribers liked or loved 86% of the coffees in their fourth box, up from 62% in their first. Across all coffees rated in the Siip app, that share is 76%.

Based on ratings in the Siip app between June 1 and October 10, 2026. People chose these coffees themselves, so this is not a blind tasting. Subscription box ratings are from Siip subscribers between April 22 and October 4, 2026. The quote is a note a rater added to their rating, shown as written.

Keep reading