Is Siip Coffee worth it?
Last updated: November 2026
Siip is worth it if you live in the United States and want a coffee subscription that changes based on what you actually drink, rather than on a quiz you filled in once. Subscribers liked or loved 62% of the coffees in their first box and 86% by the fourth box. Plans are priced by the coffees they pick from: Classic around $18 a bag, Craft around $24 and Reserve around $30, with free shipping. It is the wrong choice if you want to pick every bag yourself, want the biggest catalog, or live outside the US, where only the free app is available. We make Siip, so read this as a description you can check, not a verdict.
Why we are writing this ourselves
We make Siip, so this page is not a review. It sets out what Siip is, what it costs and where it loses to the alternatives, so you can check each point. Competitor prices are dated and link to their sources.
What Siip is
Two things that share one taste profile.
The first is a free app, on iPhone and Android, anywhere in the world. Take a photo of a specialty coffee bag and Siip shows the coffee's origin, variety, process and flavors, and how well it matches your taste. After a cup you answer one question: how was this coffee? Every rating updates your taste profile. The app has more than 10,000 users and a 4.8 star rating on the App Store.
The second is the Siip coffee subscription, which ships within the United States. Siip picks coffee from that same taste profile, from 330 coffees from 29 US roasters. You choose 1 to 5 bags a box and a box every 1 to 6 weeks. Each box comes from one roaster, and the roaster changes from box to box. When the coffee arrives you rate it, and the next box is picked from the updated profile.
The roasters include Onyx Coffee Lab, George Howell Coffee, Equator Coffees, Joe Coffee, Cat & Cloud, Ruby Coffee Roasters, Panther Coffee and Linea Caffe. We pick our roasters for their long-standing relationships with the farmers they buy from; many of our roasters have bought from the same farms for years.
The argument for
Most subscriptions ask what you like once, at signup, and act on that answer from then on. The trouble is that people describe their taste poorly. In Siip's data, 6 in 10 people tell Siip they prefer medium roast, and then they rate lighter roasts higher.
People know whether they liked a cup. They just can't always say why, and a quiz asks why.
So Siip asks the question people can answer. Every rating updates your profile and your match scores. Because the app reads any bag, a rating you give a café coffee counts as much as one you give a coffee we sent. The result shows in how subscribers rated their boxes: 62% of first-box coffees were liked or loved, and 86% by the fourth box. Across all coffees rated in the Siip app, the share is 76%.
Over time the app also shows you what your ratings lean toward, and that is often the part people value most. Richie S., a subscriber: "If you asked me six months ago what coffees I like, my answer would have been dark roast with a bunch of cream. Now, I'd tell you it's probably somewhere from Nicaragua, probably a medium roast, with notes of nuts or chocolate."
The Reserve plan includes rare lots and Cup of Excellence coffees, and Siip is a Cup of Excellence partner.
The argument against
You don't pick the bag. Siip chooses. You see the coffees in your first box before you pay, and you can see an upcoming coffee in the app and swap it, but the default is to trust the match. If you like scrolling a catalog and ordering the exact coffee you read about, Trade or MistoBox will suit you better.
The pool is smaller. Siip picks from 330 coffees from 29 roasters. Trade lists more than 500 coffees and MistoBox lists 600+ from 60+ roasters (Trade, MistoBox, checked November 2026). If you want the widest catalog, they have it.
The subscription is US only. The app works anywhere. The coffee doesn't ship abroad yet.
Bags vary in size. They are the roaster's own bags. Most are 10 to 12 oz; a few roasters use 8 or 9 oz.
What it costs
| Plan | Coffees sell for around | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Classic | $18 a bag | A good place to start |
| Craft | $24 a bag | The widest choice, and what most subscribers pick |
| Reserve | $30 a bag | Includes rare lots and Cup of Excellence coffees |
Shipping is free on every plan. The plan sets the price of the coffees Siip picks from, not how well they match; the matching is the same at every price. You pay per bag, and you can skip, pause or cancel anytime in the app.
For comparison, checked November 2026: Trade is $16.99 to $21.99 a bag plus $3.99 shipping per order unless you prepay (Trade). MistoBox is from $20 a bag with free subscription shipping (MistoBox). Atlas is $17 for a 12 oz bag plus a flat shipping fee, and Bean Box is $18 to $21.50 a bag plus a flat shipping fee (Taste of Home, Bean Box). Our cost per month page has the full table.
Who should try it
Try Siip if you are still working out what you like, and you would rather have the choosing done well than do it yourself.
The cheap way to find out is the app. Rate a few coffees you already have. After ten or so ratings, look at whether the match scores agree with your own opinion. If they do, the subscription will pick well for you. If they don't, you have lost nothing.
Sources
Checked November 2026:
- Siip: coffee subscription, plans, shipping and box ratings (subscriber ratings April 22 to October 4, 2026).
- Trade Coffee, homepage and subscription tiers.
- MistoBox, homepage and subscribe page.
- Bean Box, coffee subscriptions.
- Taste of Home, The Best Coffee Subscription Boxes, updated November 5, 2026: Atlas price.